First of all, you want to get quotes from several companies. Remember, if you can save even $ 8.00- $ 10.00 per month, that can add up to a nice amount over a years time. It will either be in your pocket or your agents. Ask about ALL of the costs involved. Just knowing the monthly payments is not good enough and may be costing you money in the long run.
Ask about what all is covered in the policy you choose. If you have an agent that really cares about your coverage they will take the time to compare rates through the companies that are their carriers. They will be able to compare rates through all those companies as well as the coverage that is provided for the quote offered. Make sure you review your policy thoroughly and ask questions if you are not sure what your policy consists of. Also look for coverage for your property as well. Are there buildings, barns, etc. if so, make sure you ask if they are covered as well.
You can ask for a raised deductible. This can save you from 15 - 40 % on a homeowners policy. The higher the deductible the more the savings.
Take steps to make your home stronger against damage. Storm shutters, stronger roofing materials, reinforement, etc. mention any that apply, they will save you money.
Ask your agent about "bundling" your policy.
This simply means if you already have policies with the company, you can ask for a bundled rate. Usually it would include your auto insurance, homeowners insurance, business insurance, etc. Most agencies are able to offer substantial discounts for a bundled policy.
Things to remember
Know your budget and stick with it.
Ask family and friends for recommendations of agents and companies they feel are trustworthy.
Make sure your home has all the possible upgrades, these save money and need to be mentioned to your agent. Security system that is monitored, sprinkler system, burglary alarms, smoke detectors, etc. These can save up to 25 % on a policy.
Senior Citizen discounts, if you qualify remember to mention. Savings can be about 10% on a policy.
Good credit. Most companies will check your credit. You can ask, you can also search for a company that does not run a credit check.
Set up electronic payments, this will save as much as 5 % on your bill.
Do not include land value in homeowners policy. House and contents are at risk, your land the house is constructed on is not.